Published July 20, 2021

He Who Remains: The Survivor at the End of Time?

Examine this lingering mystery of the Marvel Universe with his comics history.

Have you tried Marvel Unlimited yet? It’s your all-access pass to over 28,000 Marvel comics, available at your fingertips. Sign up now to get 50% off your first month.

In the long timeline of the Marvel Universe, fans have witnessed the war between Kang the Conqueror and his future self, Immortus, play out for decades. And in the background, the Time-Keepers have alternately been Immortus’ masters (or enemies) depending on his relationship to Kang. But there’s yet one more player in this cosmic game that we know very little about: He Who Remains.

In the vast library of comics on Marvel Unlimited, there are clues that can shed some light on He Who Remains—who he is, what he actually wants, and what his existence means for the Multiverse.


He Who Remains introduces himself to Thor.
A first appearance in THOR (1966) #245!

In THOR (1966) #245, Thor: God of Thunder, Jane Foster, and their companions travelled to the Citadel at the End of Time in a bid to prevent the existence of the Time-Twisters. That’s where they encountered He Who Remains. By his own admission, He Who Remains is the last of his race and the only guardian left at eternity’s end.

It was also established that He Who Remains was the final director of the Time Variance Authority. That implies that he is human, but without proof, it’s just speculation.


The true identity of He Who Remains is hinted at in UNIVERSE X (2000) #9.
UNIVERSE X (2000) #9

No, although this is a popular theory.

The alternate reality story, told in UNIVERSE X (2000) #9, put forth the notion that He Who Remains is a “being who was there at the beginning,” and is guaranteed to be there when “all things end.” What is confirmed is that He Who Remains is the creator of the Time-Keepers, the enigmatic beings who bent Immortus to their will late in his life.


THOR (1966) #245
THOR (1966) #245

He Who Remains isn’t out to save the universe, because it will always come to an end. Instead, He Who Remains wants to pass on the collective knowledge of this universe to the universe that will replace it in the hopes that the new inhabitants won’t make the same mistakes as their predecessors.

That was the reason why He Who Remains created the Time-Keepers. But in some outcomes, the creatures are born as the Time-Twisters, a dangerous trio who traveled backwards in time and left destruction in their wake. Jane Foster and Thor were able to convince He Who Remains to prevent the creation of the Time-Twisters, which in turn changed their own history. In the current timeline, Thor and Jane’s journey to the future was erased, and thus they never met He Who Remains.


He Who Remains subdues Thor in THOR (1966) #245.
THOR (1966) #245

It’s unknown if He Who Remains has any powers of his own, although he was able to subdue Thor and hold him at bay. Given his ability to create the lifeforms that become the Time-Keepers (or the Time-Twisters depending on the timeline), it suggests that He Who Remains has access to technology far beyond the comprehension of current humanity.


He Who Remains creates the Time-Keepers in AVENGERS FOREVER (1998) #10.

The Time-Twisters have no mandate to guard the flow of time, and they have mercilessly attacked innocent people in their rampage. The Time-Keepers aren’t exactly angels either. In AVENGERS FOREVER (1998), the Time-Keepers ordered Immortus to eliminate timelines in which humanity became a threat to the larger universe. They went even further by attempting to change all timelines in order to prevent humanity from ever leaving Earth and exploring the cosmos. Even Immortus balked at that, and sided against his teachers. In retaliation, the Time-Keepers murdered Immortus and tried to advance Kang’s timeline instead.

To everyone’s surprise, the Time-Keepers’ machinations allowed Kang and Immortus to exist as two separate variants. Kang’s future is no longer tied to Immortus, as far as we know.


The Oracle of Siwa helps the Fantastic Four in 4 (2004) #16.
4 (2004) #16

As revealed in Marvel Knights’ 4 (2004) #16, there is a fourth Time-Keeper who was also created by He Who Remains. This Time-Keeper is separated from his siblings and stranded in ancient Egypt as the Oracle of Siwa. It’s unknown why the fourth Time-Keeper was exiled, but he did provide information to the Fantastic Four which helped them defeat their enemy Ramades, the son of Kang.


Read all of He Who Remains’ enigmatic appearances on Marvel Unlimited today, including hundreds of stories starring Kang the Conqueror, Immortus, Loki, and more!

Follow Marvel Unlimited on Twitter and Facebook to stay tuned in to weekly announcements, articles, and more, all at @MarvelUnlimited. Follow us today to join the conversation with thousands of fellow fans, and let us know what you’re reading!


DAREDEVIL #8 cover by John Romita Jr.


April 24's New Marvel Comics: The Full List

Celebrate 60 years of Daredevil, witness the greatest betrayal in X-Men history, and more in this week's comics!

ALIENS VS. AVENGERS #1 cover by Esad Ribić


Jonathan Hickman & Esad Ribić's 'Aliens Vs. Avengers' Pits the Extraterrestrial Against Earth's Mightiest Heroes

The latest comic in Marvel’s 20th Century Studios imprint launches on July 24.

BLOOD HUNT #5 cover by Pepe Larraz


'Blood Hunt' #5 Demands a Heavy Price to Bring Down the Vampire's Reign

Check out the cover for the final issue of Jed MacKay and Pepe Larraz's 'Blood Hunt,' on sale in July.

ROXXON PRESENTS: THOR (2024) #1 cover by Greg Land


What You Need to Know for 'Roxxon Presents: Thor' #1

Here's everything you need to know about 'Roxxon Presents: Thor' #1, including Thor's history with Roxxon, Roxxon's multimedia effort to ruin Thor's public image, and more.